Setting up SPF is usually one of the first steps in email authentication. But as businesses add marketing tools, CRM systems, helpdesk platforms, and transactional email services, DNS records often become cluttered.
One of the most common misconfigurations in 2026 is publishing multiple SPF records for the same domain.
At first glance, it may look harmless. In practice, it can completely break SPF validation and impact deliverability.
Why Multiple SPF Records Break Email
A domain must have only one valid SPF TXT record. If multiple SPF records are published, receiving mail servers treat this as a permanent error and SPF automatically fails.
According to SPF specifications, multiple records create ambiguity. Instead of merging them automatically, receiving servers return a PermError (permanent error), which can cause DMARC failure and reduce email deliverability.
In short, more SPF records do not mean more authorization. They mean misconfiguration.
What an SPF Record Actually Does
An SPF record is a DNS TXT record that lists which mail servers are authorized to send email on behalf of your domain.
When an email is received, the receiving server:
- Extracts the sending IP address.
- Queries DNS for the SPF record of the sending domain.
- Checks whether the IP is included in that record.
If the IP is authorized, SPF passes. If not, SPF fails or soft-fails.
But this logic assumes only one SPF record exists.
What Happens When Two SPF Records Exist
When a domain publishes two separate SPF TXT records, for example:
v=spf1 include:mailservice.com -all
v=spf1 include:crmplatform.com -all
The receiving server encounters a policy conflict.
Instead of combining the includes automatically, the SPF specification requires the server to treat this as a permanent error.
• SPF fails
• DMARC may fail
• Email may land in spam or be rejected
This is often misunderstood as a deliverability issue when the root cause is DNS structure.
Why This Problem Is Increasing in 2026
Businesses now use multiple cloud-based email tools simultaneously:
• Marketing automation platforms
• Customer support systems
• Transactional mail providers
• Sales engagement tools
Each provider gives its own SPF instruction. Many users mistakenly publish each instruction as a separate record.
SPF was designed to consolidate authorization into one record, not multiple.
How to Check If You Have Multiple SPF Records
Step 1: Query Your Domain’s TXT Records
Look for multiple entries beginning with:
If more than one appears, the configuration is invalid.
Step 2: Check for Flattened Records
Sometimes SPF flattening tools create unintended duplicates. Review DNS carefully to ensure only one SPF record exists.
How to Fix Multiple SPF Records
The solution is to merge all authorized senders into a single SPF record.
v=spf1 include:mailservice.com -all
v=spf1 include:crmplatform.com -all
v=spf1 include:mailservice.com include:crmplatform.com -all
This consolidates authorization into one valid record.
Watch Out for the 10 DNS Lookup Limit
SPF allows a maximum of 10 DNS lookups during evaluation.
Each include, redirect, or mechanism can trigger additional lookups.
If your merged SPF record exceeds 10 lookups, SPF fails even if only one record exists.
This is another common 2026 misconfiguration.
In complex environments, SPF flattening or restructuring may be required.
How Multiple SPF Records Affect DMARC
If SPF produces a PermError due to multiple records, DMARC cannot consider SPF as a passing authentication mechanism.
If DKIM is also misaligned or absent, DMARC fails entirely.
With p=quarantine or p=reject policies, this can lead to:
• Messages landing in spam
• Email rejection
• Decreased sender reputation
What looks like a DMARC issue is often an SPF structure issue.
Real-World Scenario
• Google Workspace for internal mail
• A CRM tool for automated campaigns
• A billing system for transactional receipts
Each provider instructs the administrator to “add this SPF record.”
Instead of merging them, three separate SPF TXT records are published.
Within days, marketing emails begin failing authentication checks.
DMARC reports show widespread SPF PermError results.
The fix is simple: consolidate into one record.
Best Practices for SPF Management
• Maintain only one SPF TXT record per domain
• Merge includes carefully
• Monitor DNS lookup count
• Review records after adding new providers
• Periodically audit DNS authentication settings
SPF misconfiguration is rarely intentional. It is usually the result of growth without consolidation.
Final Thoughts
Multiple SPF records do not increase security. They break validation.
SPF was designed to authorize sending servers through a single consolidated DNS record. Publishing multiple records introduces ambiguity that mail servers resolve by failing authentication.
If email delivery suddenly declines after adding a new provider, check your SPF structure before investigating more complex issues. Clear DNS structure remains one of the most important foundations of domain-level email security.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can subdomains have separate SPF records?
Yes. Each subdomain can publish its own SPF record. The restriction applies per domain or subdomain label.
What is an SPF PermError?
PermError is a permanent error indicating the SPF record is syntactically or structurally invalid, including having multiple SPF records.
Will removing duplicate SPF records fix deliverability immediately?
In most cases, yes. Once DNS propagates and only one valid SPF record remains, authentication stabilizes.
Is SPF still necessary in 2026?
Yes. SPF remains a foundational component of email authentication, but it must work alongside DKIM and DMARC.
.png&w=3840&q=75)
.png&w=2048&q=75)
